Difference between Open Ended and Closed Ended Mutual Funds

Open ended vs Closed Ended Mutual Funds

The categories of mutual funds you can invest in either belongs to open ended or closed ended mutual funds. The main difference between open ended and closed ended mutual funds is liquidity and the way we invest in these funds. Open ended funds are available for buying and selling anytime we want, where as closed ended funds are available for buying during specific time frame – like during NFO (New Fund Offering) and available for redemptions only after maturity. Some closed ended funds after maturity gets either gets converted to open ended fund or the assets are allocated to existing open ended fund after taking investor’s consent.

Let us understand more about open ended and closed ended mutual funds in detail.

What are open Ended mutual funds?

  • Open ended mutual funds are the most common category of funds where the fund is open or available for buying and selling anytime you want
  • You can invest via SIP (Systematic Investment Plan) or Lump sum investment in open ended mutual funds
  • Based on the underlying stocks in these funds, the NAV (Net Asset Value) is updated on daily basis in these mutual funds
  • Open ended mutual funds are liquid in nature since you can withdraw the funds anytime you want and there is no maturity period unlike closed ended mutual funds
  • At the end of trading day, the NAV of mutual fund is calculated based on the underlying stocks available in it’s portfolio
  • Some of the examples of open ended mutual funds include HDFC Index Fund Sensex Plan, ICICI Prudential bluechip fund, Mirae Asset Emerging Bluechip fund, etc.
  • While analyzing mutual funds, you can check whether it dalls under open ended or closed ended mutual fund

ALSO READ: All Types of Mutual Funds in India

Advantages of Open Ended Mutual Funds

There are multiple advantage of open ended mutual funds

  • Liquidity: Since open ended mutual funds can be bought and sold anytime, these funds are liquid in nature – which means you can sell the mutual fund units anytime you want based on your requirements. It helps you to achieve your goals before time if wealth accumulation is complete
  • Systematic Investment: You can also invest systematically using SIP, in which case you invest in open ended mutual fund every month based on your financial goal tenure. And once your goal is complete, you can redeem or withdraw the mutual fund units
  • Track Record Availability: The track record of open ended funds are available for performance analysis purpose like daily or monthly NAV changes, and you can take decision whether to continue with same mutual fund or is it time to switch to another fund for better mutual fund returns

Disadvantages of Open Ended Mutual Funds

There are certain disadvantages of open ended mutual funds listed below:

  • Market Risk: Since the NAV of these funds are updated on daily basis and is available as track record, you can see the volatility in the market and see it as a risk of market goes down temporarily. Here some investors give high priority to their emotions and tend to sell the mutual fund units while bearing losses due to short term changes. Best strategy would be to hold for long term and trust the fund manager for better returns from these mutual funds
  • Asset Composition: The underlying stocks or Assets are selected by fund manager and investors cannot say much about the Asset composition that must be present in these mutual funds, which is another limitation

Love Reading Books? Here are some of the Best Books you can Read: (WITH LINKS)

More Recommended Books Here

What are Closed Ended Mutual Funds?

  • Closed ended mutual funds are the category of funds that are available for buying only during specific time frame like during NFO (New fund offering) launch
  • These funds are not available for active buying and selling like open ended funds
  • Closed ended funds have a lock in period after which you can redeem the mutual fund units for returns
  • Since the maturity period of closed ended funds can be long term, you stay invested in these funds for long term and get better returns
  • Some closed ended funds either get converted to open ended funds after lock in period or the assets get allocated to existing open ended fund, to be available for active buying and selling of these funds, only after taking consent from existing investors
  • Due to lock in period, closed ended funds are not liquid in nature
  • The track record of these funds are not available for performance overview purpose

ALSO READ: What is Equity Mutual Funds, Features and Benefits

Advantages of Closed Ended Mutual Funds

Below are some of the advantages of closed ended mutual funds

  • Stable Assets: Since close ended mutual funds allow buying and selling only during specific time frame, the fund manager gets the opportunity to allocate the assets to required underlying stocks over long term
  • Long Term Goals: You can achieve your long terms goals with closed ended mutual fund by staying invested up to the lock in period of these funds

Disadvantages of Closed Ended Mutual Funds

Below are some disadvantages of closed ended mutual funds:

  • Liquidity: Closed ended mutual funds are not liquid in nature, which means you cannot withdraw from these funds even when you need them, due to their lock in period
  • Lump sum Investing: These funds allow only lump sum investing during the fund launch. You cannot make systematic investments in these funds every month to gradually move towards your financial goal. This lump sum investing can make your investment risky over short term
  • No Track Record Available: There is no track record available for closed ended mutual funds, regarding the NAV (Net Asset Value) or other factors

ALSO READ: What is ELSS Mutual Funds to Save Income Tax

Difference between Open Ended and Closed Ended Mutual Funds

Let us now see the comparison and Difference between Open Ended and Closed Ended Mutual Funds in below table:

FactorsOpen Ended Mutual FundsClosed Ended Mutual Funds
LiquidityThese funds can be sold anytime you want based on your requirements, hence they are liquid in natureThese funds have a lock in period during which they cannot be sold, hence they are not liquid
Track RecordThe track record of these funds are available for performance overview purposeTrack record of closed ended mutual funds are not available
Ways to InvestYou can either invest via SIP or lump sum investment, since these funds are available for buying anytimeOnly lump sum investing is allowed since the buying period is specific during a time frame, like NFO
Rupee Cost AveragingSince you can invest in open ended funds via SIP, you get the benefit of rupee cost averaging by investing every monthClosed ended fuds do not five benefit of rupee cost averaging due to lump sum investing
Investment AmountsYou can start investing with small amount like Rs. 500 or Rs. 1000The minimum amount in closed ended fund can be Rs. 5000 or more
Difference between Open Ended and Closed Ended Mutual Funds

These are some of the Differences between Open Ended and Closed Ended Mutual Funds.

Conclusion

Open ended mutual funds are available for buying and selling anytime you want based on your requirements, where as closed ended mutual funds can be bought only during specific time frame like in NFO launch and have a lock in period associated with it.

You can invest via SIP or lump sum in open ended funds, but closed ended funds only allow lump sum investing.

Open ended vs closed ended fund, which is better for you? Depends on your financial goals. If you can make lump sum investing and do not need these funds for next 5 to 7 years, you can go for closed ended funds and lock them for these many years, but if you are just getting started with investing, than open ended funds will be suitable for so that yo can invest via SIP and learn from these funds after seeing their track records over a period of time.

Some more Reading:

Frequently Asked Questions

What is open ended fund with example?

Open ended fund is the mutual fund category that is available for buying and selling anytime you want. You can withdraw from these funds based on your requirement, unlike closed ended funds that have lock in period on investments. Some examples of open ended fund include HDFC Index Fund Sensex Plan, ICICI Pridential Bluechip fund, Mirae Asset Emerging bluechip fund, and many other that are open for subscription anytime you want to buy them.

Is SIP possible in open ended funds?

Yes SIP is possible in open ended mutual fund since they are open for buying every time. Closed ended mutual fund do not allow SIP since they are open for buying only during specific time frame.

Are open-end funds active or passive?

Most open ended funds are actively managed by fund managers, which means they are actively analyzing underlying stocks to buy or sell them to maximize your returns. But there are some open ended funds, like index mutual funds which are passively managed as well, by investing only in indices like sensex and nifty index.

Get EARLY Retirement!

Use Retirement Excel Calculator that will help you to Retire Early.
Click below button to download Retirement Calculator in Excel:

Download Retirement Excel

Watch how Retirement Calculator in Excel Works

Income Tax Calculator App – FinCalC

For Income Tax Calculation on your mobile device, you can Download my Android App “FinCalC” which I have developed for you to make your income tax calculation easy.

What you can do with this mobile App?

  • Calculate Income Tax for new FY 2024-25 and previous FY 2023-24
  • Enter estimated Investments to check income tax with Old and New Tax Regime
  • Save income tax details and track regularly
  • Know how much to invest more to save income tax
  • More calculators including PPF, SIP returns, Savings account interest and lot more
Download Income Tax Calculator APP from play store
Download Income Tax Calculator APP from play store

Use Popular Calculators:

I’d love to hear from you if you have any queries about Personal Finance and Money Management.

JOIN Telegram Group and stay updated with latest Personal Finance News and Topics.

Download our Free Android App – FinCalC to Calculate Income Tax and Interest on various small Saving Schemes in India including PPF, NSC, SIP and lot more.

Follow the Blog and Subscribe to YouTube Channel to stay updated about Personal Finance and Money Management topics.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *